The American Refit Advantage: What Six Industry Leaders Shared at FLIBS 2026

On Thursday, October 29, I had the privilege of hosting The American Refit Advantage Panel on the RefitX Stage in the Yacht Builders Tent at the Fort Lauderdale International Boat Show. For one hour during the busiest week of the yachting year, five leaders from across the refit industry joined me to answer a question our industry does not ask often enough.

The United States has the design talent, shipyard infrastructure, specialized trades and technical expertise to execute even the most ambitious superyacht refits. So why are so many major projects still sent overseas?

The Panel

  • Jamie Benoit, naval architect and marine engineer, Murray & Associates
  • George Whitehouse, Director of Business Development and Sales, Derecktor Shipyards
  • Colin Lord, Project Manager, Maritime Project Solutions
  • Phil Purcell, President and CEO, Marine Industries Association of South Florida (MIASF), and RefitX
  • Michael Merritt, CEO, Merritt
  • and myself, Patrick Knowles, for Patrick Knowles Designs and The Quintessential Yachtsman

Several of us have worked together for twenty years or more. That history showed in the conversation, which covered the full life of a refit, from the first drawing to the final reveal.

The American Refit Advantage panel speaking on the RefitX Stage at FLIBS 2026
The panel in session on the RefitX Stage, October 29.

The Case for Refitting at Home

The first answer was geography. Jamie Benoit pointed out that a yacht’s calendar is measured in seasons, and every owner wants to know how much of a season a refit will cost them. From South Florida, a yacht can finish its work and go straight into the Caribbean, the Bahamas or a New England summer helping “save a season”. He added that across refits all over the country, at yards with every kind of lift and dock, he could not think of a single limitation they had run into.

Phil Purcell, who leads the Marine Industries Association of South Florida, the association that owns the Fort Lauderdale International Boat Show, made the economic case. Owners refitting here can use foreign trade zones, state sales tax caps and federal bonus depreciation. He also offered an analogy I have repeated since: a collector who owns a Ferrari does not ship it back to Italy for restoration. He finds the best restorer at home.

For my part, the answer is convenience, and it is bigger than it sounds. Most of our clients are on the East Coast or the Gulf Coast. When the refit is here, we can meet the owner in the morning, walk the yacht at the shipyard together, and everyone is home with the rest of the day intact. A single site visit overseas can take several days.

When a Problem Needs Hands, Not a Video Call

Our moderator asked for a real example of a problem solved faster because the whole team was in one place. I had one from that very week.

Jamie Benoit, Colin Lord and I are working together on a refit for an owner who is deeply involved and genuinely grateful for the work, and that respect runs through the whole team. An unexpected plumbing issue came up that had to be solved before the next trades could move in. We tried to work it through on a WhatsApp video, and it simply could not be done that way. From my office window I could see the buildings in front of the shipyard. I was on board within twenty minutes, and we resolved it in about an hour.

I have worked on new builds overseas where every remote tool was exhausted and the problem was still there. Technology can only do so much. Sometimes I need to stand in front of the craftsman and have him show me with his hands. You cannot put a price on that.

Outdated Perceptions We Would Like to Retire

Each panelist was asked, which old assumptions about American refits should be retired for good.

“You have to take the yacht back to its builder.” Jamie compared this to driving a car back to the dealership where you bought it for every oil change. A builder is, at heart, an integrator of marine trades, and most yards rely on large networks of subcontractors. That is exactly what the American refit community is.

“American quality is not at the same level.” Michael Merritt, whose company is now nearly 60 years old, called that flatly untrue. His point was that an owner who refits here supports the home team without sacrificing anything: the result is as good or better.

“Nobody here is doing major work.” George Whitehouse noted that his yard alone has completed more than ten major refits in the past year. Almost no one knows, because the yards respect their owners’ privacy and do not publicize names. The misperception, he said, often starts within our own industry, in how little we tell our own story.

Phil challenged all of us to be proactive, to argue from facts rather than aspiration, and to go out and win the work. Colin Lord’s answer was the shortest of the day: the only thing that is truly old fashioned is a bad attitude about the situation. We can win the work back.

My own answer looked to the past but spoke of the efficiencies of today. I entered this industry at the close of what I consider the golden age of yachting, when interiors were stick built on board and you left each day smelling like a wood shop. I am grateful I saw it. But today’s owners live on a different schedule, and the inefficiency that came with that era has to go. The answer is a process that brings every discipline together early. When a firm like Merritt takes our design and works the HVAC, plumbing and electrical into it from the start, the trades can begin fabrication long before the yacht arrives. When the designer, the fabricator, the shipyard and the owner are all in the United States, that process runs at its most efficient. That efficiency belongs in any honest comparison of what a refit costs.

Building the Next Generation of Craftspeople

A question that was not on our original list drew some of the most passionate answers: how do we bring young people into this work? Colin described his firm’s work with the Chapman School toward an apprenticeship program. Michael described the 5,000 square foot training facility Merritt has built, where four full time instructors teach a workforce of more than 400, and how he now recruits sculptors and art school graduates who love to work with their hands. Phil spoke about MIASF’s apprenticeship efforts and SaltyJobs.org, a video series built to reach young people where they actually spend their time.

My view is that this begins in school. When wood shop and metal shop disappeared, young people lost their first chance to discover the satisfaction of making something by hand. As more of their world becomes screens and software, I believe many of them will go looking for exactly that. We need to be ready with the door open.

The One Thing to Confirm Before You Sign

We closed by asking each panelist for the one thing an owner should make sure of before signing a refit contract, here or anywhere else in the world.

George’s answer was planning: how well the project was planned, and who is helping you plan it. Jamie’s was a clear line between what is included in the scope and what is excluded, because a refit modifies something that already exists. Michael asked whether the owner truly understands the time they themselves will need to give the project, because the yard and the design team cannot succeed without the owner.

My advice is the one I give every owner considering a refit. Before you sign, be certain that your team has articulated what you have in mind, fully and to your satisfaction, to the shipyard before the yacht is ever touched. If that has not happened, you are opening yourself up to change orders, delays and a shifting schedule. Everything that follows depends on that one step.

My thanks to Jamie Benoit, George Whitehouse, Colin Lord, Phil Purcell and Michael Merritt for giving their time during the busiest week of the year, to RefitX for the stage, and to everyone who filled the tent and brought such good questions. If you are considering a refit, or would simply like to talk through what is possible, I would welcome the conversation.

Start the Conversation